Home  /  Stories  / 

Where are the heroines?

03 Apr 2013
New Zealand Post Children’s Book Awards judges have raised concerns about the quality of entries and a lack of strong female characters.

An impressive variety of books make up the finalists of this year’s New Zealand Post Children’s Book Awards.  And Chief Judge Bernard Beckett says it suggests we have a group of New Zealand writers who are confident enough to pursue their own interests.

An impressive variety of books make up the finalists of this year’s New Zealand Post Children’s Book Awards.  And Chief Judge Bernard Beckett says it suggests we have a group of New Zealand writers who are confident enough to pursue their own interests.

In all, 19 books have been selected as finalists across four categories: best picture book, junior fiction, young adult and non-fiction. The winners from each category will be announced in June. 

War was a dominant theme among this year’s entries - a year before the centenary of the start of the First World War.

Bernard said: “As judges, we were pleased to see coverage given to conflicts less likely to be known to young readers such as The Boer War or the conflict in Malaysia. Prominence was also given to the bravery of those who resisted armed conflict, both in World War One and at Parihaka – that strikes us as tremendously important.”

The finalists were chosen from hundreds of entries read by the panel of three judges - children’s literature expert and author Eirlys Hunter, presenter of Radio New Zealand’s Arts on Sunday programme, Lynn Freeman and author Bernard Beckett.  

The judges said it was a privilege to read and assess New Zealand’s best books for children and young adults in 2012.

However, the judges raised concerns over the many entries that had great potential but didn’t meet the standard required to become a finalist.

“A large number of books were crying out for a more considered editing or design process: books with clear potential that needed only another careful draft; delightful children’s stories let down by the illustrations or design layout. To see such possibilities unrealised was a clear frustration for us.”

“We were also surprised to see how few strong female characters there were in these pages. Young girls are in danger of seeing themselves once again as serving only decorative roles in stories, and we hope this is more a blip than the beginning of a retrograde trend.”

School-aged children and young adults can now vote for their favourite books from among the finalists for the coveted Children’s Choice Award - this option will be available later today.
 
The finalists are...

Picture Book   

A Great Cake by Tina Matthews

Melu by Kyle Mewburn, Ali Teo & John O’Reilly – Central Otago

Mister Whistler by Margaret Mahy & Gavin Bishop - Christchurch

Mr Bear Branches and the Cloud Conundrum by Terri Rose Baynton - Taupo

Remember That November / Maumahara ki tera Noema by Jennifer Beck, Lindy Fisher & Kawata Teepa – Wellington

Junior Fiction  

The ACB with Honora Lee by Kate De Goldi & Gregory O’Brien – Wadestown, Wellington

The Queen and the Nobody Boy (A Tale of Fontania) by Barbara Else – Lower Hutt, Wellington

My Brother's War by David Hill – New Plymouth

Red Rocks by Rachael King – St Albans, Christchurch

Uncle Trev and His Whistling Bull by Jack Lasenby – Aro Valley, Wellington

Young Adult Fiction  

Earth Dragon, Fire Hare by Ken Catran – Waimate, South Canterbury

Into the River by Ted Dawe – Mt Eden, Auckland

The Nature of Ash by Mandy Hager – Paraparaumu, Wellington

Reach by Hugh Brown – Paekakariki, Wellington

Snakes and Ladders by Mary-anne Scott – Havelock North

Non-fiction

100 Amazing Tales From Aotearoa by Simon Morton & Riria Hotere – Northland, Wellington

Kiwi: the real story by Annemarie Florian & Heather Hunt – Whangarei

Taketakerau, The Millennium Tree by Marnie Anstis, Patricia Howitt & Kelly Spencer – Bay of Plenty

At the Beach: Explore & Discover the New Zealand Seashore by Ned Barraud & Gillian Candler – Pukerua Bay, Wellington

Note: Four finalists were selected in the non-fiction category, compared to five in the other categories. The judges felt the books selected represented the best on offer.

Media Release: New Zealand Post Children's Book Awards